Operetta is directing the school's spring musical, Screaming in the Drain, and a long line of ghouls wait outside the Clawditorium for their chance to audition for the show, including Ghoulia. Lagoona joins her to wish her luck, but Ghoulia admits she's having second thoughts about trying. Lagoona reminds her that she tries out for the musical every year, but Toralei laughs that Ghoulia never gets a role, due to her singing voice being so shrill that it shatters glass and scares away animals. Lagoona tells Ghoulia that you never know what'll happen unless you try, and encourages her to do her best.
Suddenly the door opens and Operetta lets Catty Noir out, telling her that she nailed the part. Upon seeing this, every ghoul in the queue decides to give up and walk away. Even Lagoona throws up her arms in defeat, claiming there's no way anyone could beat out a famous pop star like Catty. Ghoulia is left alone, and is about to walk away when Operetta spots her and asks if she still wants to audition.
Some time later the musical opens, and to everyone's surprise, Ghoulia is in the lead role. Lagoona explains that Catty was actually auditioning for the secondary role for a change, and since Ghoulia was the only other person who tried out, she got the lead part. Ghoulia and Catty sing together on stage, and despite Ghoulia's voice shattering the spotlights and windows, they receive a standing ovation.
- The title of the webisode is a play on the term "stage fright".
- The musical's title, Screaming in the Drain, is a play on the 1952 musical Singin' in the Rain.
- If Toralei also tried out, doesn't that mean that she literally have just as chance as winning as Ghoulia, since Operetta had to choose between only two people?