The ghouls work together to help Scarah Screams and Invisi Billy share their true feelings.
Cleo, Draculaura, and Frankie discover that Scarah Screams harbors feelings for Invisi Billy. They ask her why she doesn't just go talk with him about it, and she explains that she might hear him think he doesn't like her, which she knows she couldn't handle. As Scarah leaves somberly, Clawd meets up with Draculaura, who immediately spills everything Scarah just said. Clawd promises to talk with Invisi Billy to see if he can be prompted to act.
In the creepateria, Clawd asks Invisi Billy about Scarah and finds that he likes her too, but that he is afraid she doesn't like him and will respond badly if she'd mindread that he likes her. Clawd reports back to Cleo and Frankie, and though it seems like they are stuck, Frankie develops an idea to get around the problem. They prepare a picnic for two at the cemetery and Clawd tells Invisi Billy that Scarah has a date there with another boy. Meanwhile, Cleo tells Draculaura that Invisi Billy has a date at the cemetery with another girl. They agree that they should not tell Scarah, but as they part ways, Draculaura encounters her. Draculaura desperately thinks of not thinking of Invisi Billy's date, which Scarah picks up.
As bet on, Scarah and Invisi Billy both make their way to the cemetery that evening to find out who their rival is. To their surprise, they find no one but their equally surprised crush. It doesn't take them long to figure out they've been tricked. Grateful, amused, and happy, the two finally confess their mutual feelings. They have their picnic together and make sure to meet up with and thank their friends the next day.
- Scarah and Invisi Billy confess their feelings for each other in this webisode, meaning it occurs before the TV special "13 Wishes", which identified them as a couple.
- Buzz Wingman receives a name in this webisode, lifting him out of backgrounder status and onto character status.