Headless Headmistress Bloodgood charges the ghouls with picking the next Monster High Creature of the Year.
Headless Headmistress Bloodgood has to decide who of the Monster High staff deserves to be the Creature of the Year. She has reduced the candidates to Mr. Hackington and Mr. Rotter, and enlists Frankie and her friends to help pick between the two teachers.
Lagoona objects to Hackington getting the award, as she remembers his anti-phibian sentiments from when she and Gil had to take care of a gargoyle egg all too well. Cleo also objects on grounds that Hackington enjoys to torment his students by laughing at their misery and threatening they'll fail his class. Bloodgood is shocked to hear this and notes that the award will go to Rotter then. Cleo objects to that candidate too, stating that he is too hard on the students. Frankie adds to that the time he accused several students of taking his glasses, while they were only gone due to his own inattentiveness.
Bloodgood agrees that neither candidate is the kind she wants to hand the Creature of the Year award. Readying herself to start her selection anew with Nightmare's help, Frankie suggests to award her steadfast assistant. And so, Bloodgood announces Nightmare as the Creature of the Year during the ceremony, much to the chagrin of Rotter and Hackington. Everyone else cheers and Nightmare proudly leaves the stage, though not before happily snorting some flames towards the two disqualified teachers.
- The scene of Cleo gasping at Bloodgood's announcement is taken from "Dueling Personality", but zoomed in on Cleo to hide that she's wearing her fearleader uniform. Nonetheless, it is still shortly visible.
- During the begining of the websode bloodgood's neckline was missing.
- The early portion of the webisode recycles a shot from "Frightday the 13th" and animation from "Dueling Personality". The animation pieces used when Bloodgood names the two teachers are from "Queen of the Scammed" and "Fear the Book".
- "Creature of the Year" is the fourth of a handful of clip shows in Volume 3. The recycled scenes are:
- Lagoona recalls about Hack a scene from Volume 1, "Hatch Me If You Can".
- Cleo recalls about Hack, in order, a scene from Volume 2, "Screech to the Beach", a scene from Volume 1, "Hatch Me If You Can", and Volume 3, "Honey, I Shrunk the Ghouls".
- Cleo recalls about Rotter a scene from Volume 1, "Idol Threat".
- Frankie recalls about Rotter a scene from Volume 3, "Creepfast Club".